Ever since it was first introduced back in 1956, Yahtzee has been one of the most popular dice games of all time. Its popularity has spawned quite a few spinoff games over the years. One of those spinoff games was the 2008 game Yahtzee Free For All created by Richard Borg (Liar’s Dice, Memoir ’44). Yahtzee Free For All takes the dice rolling mechanics from the original game and includes a mechanic where players can steal cards claimed by the other players. Personally I have always found Yahtzee to be more of a take it or leave it game. I don’t mind playing Yahtzee but I have played quite a few dice games that are considerably better. I was intrigued by Yahtzee Free For All though as I thought it could add something new to Yahtzee ultimately making it a better game. Yahtzee Free For All succeeds in improving on its predecessor but ends up playing almost identically like a lot of other dice games.
How to Play Yahtzee Free For All
- Layout the gameboard and place it in the middle of the table.
- Remove the six Yahtzee cards and set them near the gameboard.
- Shuffle the rest of the cards and place them facedown on the gameboard. Take the top three cards and place one on each card space on the gameboard.
- Place the chips to the side of the gameboard.
- Each player takes five dice.
- Choose which player will start the game.
Playing the Game
If a player has a card on their home space at the beginning of their turn, they place the card face down in front of them to indicate that the card is banked.
The player rolls all five of their dice. They are either trying to form the pattern shown on one of the cards in the middle of the gameboard or a card on one of the other players’ home spaces. The player can re-roll any or all of their dice up to two times.
If after any of the three rolls a player matches one of the cards in the middle of the gameboard, they can take the card and place it face up on their home space. They take the chips underneath the card they took. If you ever roll six of the same number you can take one of the Yahtzee cards. The player will place the dice they rolled into their section of the gameboard so the other players can see what they need to beat in order to steal the card.
The player also has the option of stealing a card from one of the other players’ home spaces. In order to steal a card from a player’s home space you must roll a combination that beats the combination that they rolled to take the card. If you beat another player’s combination, you take their card and place it on your home space. Place the dice you rolled into your section of the gameboard to show the other players what you rolled to get the card. You beat another player’s combination in the following ways:
- Number Card: Roll more of the number than the previous player.
- Combo Card: You must match the combo and have a higher dice total than the previous player.
- Yahtzee Card: You must roll a Yahtzee with a higher number than the previous player.
If a player doesn’t roll a combination that lets them claim a card, they end their turn without scoring any points.
Before the next player takes their turn, the players will deal with the cards in the middle of the board. If a player claimed one of the center cards, add the next card from the draw pile to the spot that is now vacant. If the player didn’t take one of the center cards (does not include Yahtzee cards), place one chip below each center card.
End of Game
The game ends in one of two ways:
- One of the middle cards are claimed and there are no cards left to fill in the vacant space.
- There are not enough chips to place one under all of the center cards.
All of the players will tally the points they earned during the game. The players will score points equal to what is printed on the cards they collected. They will also score one point for each chip they collected. The player with the most points wins the game.
My Thoughts on Yahtzee Free For All
While I thought Yahtzee Free For All was a solid game that I had fun playing, after playing so many different dice games over the years it is hard to deny that it is far from an original game. The idea of having three rolls to get different dice combinations has been used by a lot of dice games over the years as it was a mechanic first introduced by Yacht and the original Yahtzee. Yahtzee Free For All tries to change things up by having players claim cards for certain combinations that the other players can end up stealing. This may sound like an original idea and yet we have reviewed games in the past here on Geeky Hobbies that basically have the same mechanic (Easy Come Easy Go, Knights/Knatsch). Due to this fact Yahtzee Free For All is not as original as it first appears. Even though it is not highly original I am going to try to judge the game on its own merit and not the fact that it isn’t particularly original.
The basics of Yahtzee Free For All play like your typical dice rolling game. You get three rolls to try to and roll certain combinations. The mechanics are fun enough if you like dice rolling games. Basically if you like Yahtzee or other similar dice games you should feel right at home with Yahtzee Free For All. What distinguishes Yahtzee Free For All from its predecessor and other similar dice games is the idea of being able to steal other players’ cards. Once you claim a card all of the other players have one opportunity to steal the card from you. If it gets back to your turn and no one has stolen the card, you get to bank the card and will score the corresponding points at the end of the game. This is easily the best addition to the game as it actually succeeds at adding some player interaction to Yahtzee a game that you basically play alone and then compare scores at the end. Being able to have your card stolen by another player keeps you invested in the game on other players’ turns. Being able to steal cards from the players adds a little strategy as you may pursue a combination just to take points away from another player.
While I generally liked the ability to steal cards from the other players, it can be a pretty harsh penalty for a player to have one of their cards stolen. As most players will be able to meet one of the card combinations on their turn, having your card stolen leads to you losing points on all of the other players. This also leads to a situation where the players who are behind can try to gang up on the player in first in order to prevent them from banking cards. While the player in the lead could get a combo that would be hard to beat, if all of the players work together it is not hard to prevent a player from scoring points.
In most of these type of dice rolling games that I have played in the past, the best strategy is usually to try and steal cards from the other players whenever possible as you gain a card while an opponent loses one. This is one area where I actually think Yahtzee Free For All stands out. I really like the idea that whenever a player takes a card from another player or fails to take any cards, one chip is added to every card in the middle of the gameboard. As more chips get added to the cards in the middle, it becomes really enticing to go for one of the cards in the middle rather than trying to steal a card from another player. As each chip is worth one point, you could score several points claiming a center card with no risk of losing those points. The chips give players some interesting decisions as you have to decide between taking some free points or preventing another player from scoring points.
One area where I think Yahtzee Free For All is worse than the other games is in the variety of the cards. While there is a limit on the different types of combinations you can roll with five six sided dice, there is little variety in the cards in Yahtzee Free For All. The cards in Yahtzee Free For All basically boil down to rolling three/four of a kind, rolling a short/long straight, rolling as many of a certain number as possible, rolling a full house, or rolling the highest total number. Other similar dice games that I have played have quite a bit more variety in the type of combinations that you can roll. With a limited number of combinations it gets a little boring after a while rolling the same combinations over and over again. It got so bad that at one point all three cards in the middle were basically the same.
While on the topic of combinations I want to quickly mention that rolling a Yahtzee in the game is huge. It is pretty hard to roll a Yahtzee but if you are able to there is a good chance that you are going to win the game. I was pretty far behind the other players in a game due to bad luck and players stealing several of my cards. I eventually was able to roll a Yahtzee though which catapulted me to first place. One lucky roll took me from last to first and ultimately won me the game. With how hard it is to roll a Yahtzee it should be worth the most points but I think it is a little overpowered. Unless you roll poorly the rest of the game, a player that rolls a Yahtzee is likely going to win the game. While it makes sense to make the Yahtzee an even ten points, I think it should have been reduced to seven or eight points so it isn’t quite as powerful.
On the whole there is some strategy in Yahtzee Free For All but it is mostly driven by luck. You will occasionally have some decisions to make but they are usually pretty obvious as your first roll will likely show you what combination you should try to pursue. You will usually pursue whatever combination you roll the most dice for but you can decide to pursue a card that is worth more points or a card that you can steal from another player. With there not being a lot of strategy in the game, luck is usually going to be the deciding factor in who ultimately wins the game. The player who rolls the best is likely going to win the game.
In general I would say the components for Yahtzee Free For All are solid even though it has arguably one of the weirdest boxes that I have ever seen. The dice feel a little cheap and are nothing special. The cards are thicker than I would have expected. The artwork is nothing special but it gets right to the point. The chips are shaped strangely but are pretty solid. The weirdest thing about the components is that the game decided it had to have a box shaped like a die. That in itself is not that bad except that it makes the game harder to store. The hexagon shape leads to the instructions being shaped like a pinwheel though which is kind of a pain. The gameboard also ends up being used for the bottom of the box which forces it to fold up kind of strangely.
Should You Buy Yahtzee Free For All?
Yahtzee Free For All may have just tweaked the original Yahtzee with a few new mechanics but it accomplishes something most spinoff games fail to ever achieve: improving upon the original game. Yahtzee Free For All is a clearly superior game to the original Yahtzee due to some additional strategy as well as more interaction between the players. The ability to steal combo cards from the other players adds some strategy to the game as you decide whether to steal a card from another player or try for one of the cards in the middle of the gameboard. Being able to steal cards potentially leads to players ganging up on the leader but is otherwise a good addition to Yahtzee. I also liked the addition of the chips being placed on the center cards as it gives players a reason not to always try and steal cards from the other players. I can’t say that I was a huge fan of the lack of variety in the combo cards though as similar games tend to have more variety. The biggest problem that I had with Yahtzee Free For All is that there are quite a few other dice games that play basically the same but are better than Yahtzee Free For All. While I had fun with the game, there are other dice games that I would probably prefer playing.
If you don’t really care for Yahtzee or dice games in general, you probably won’t get a lot out of Yahtzee Free For All. If you like dice games though I think you will enjoy Yahtzee Free For All. If you already have another similar dice game it probably isn’t worth picking up Yahtzee Free For All because it isn’t particularly original. If you don’t already own a similar dice game though and can find Yahtzee Free For All for cheap I think it is worth picking up.
If you would like to purchase Yahtzee Free For All you can find it online: Amazon, eBay
Sunday 6th of October 2019
How to play 3 players in this game?
Do we use both home spots and dice before taking a card off a home space?
Do we use one home space and take that one card while the other home space remains empty and never used?
What do we do?
Monday 7th of October 2019
So I will preface this by saying that I don't have the rules for Yahtzee Free For All in front of me and I haven't played the game since I reviewed it. I am basing my answer on this thread I found on Board Game Geek from a person who directly asked this question to the designer of the board game.
I interpret this to mean that each player will control two of the home spaces on the board that are directly across from one another. You will then play each home space as its own thing like you are playing as two different players. The only difference is that you will take the cards scored from both spaces. This is just my interpretation of what was discussed in the thread. I would recommend checking out the link above especially since it has some variant three player rules suggested by the designer.